People often take psychiatric drugs because there’s something about themselves they don’t like—extreme low mood, threatening voices, or panic attacks. But many who’ve been diagnosed with borderline personality disorder (BPD) take drugs for the sake of others. They’re repeatedly told that their very personalities are disordered, pathological or just intolerable. This message is profoundly stigmatizing. It can contribute to isolation, loneliness, and even suicidal thoughts.
In September 2024, I talked with Dr. Shay Welch, a philosophy professor at Spelman College. Welch, who’s been diagnosed with BPD, truly writes from an insider’s perspective—a perspective that’s nearly absent from the academic literature.

Her recent paper, “Am I Safe Enough for You Now? BPD and the Forced Erasure of Personal Identity,” describes how people with BPD often feel forced to erase who they are to make others feel safe. We discuss ways of promoting more positive messaging around BPD, and creating a more tolerant and accepting society.
The title of her paper captures a theme that ran throughout our conversation: “treatment” for BPD is often less about alleviating the diagnosed person’s suffering than about making them more tolerable to other people. She describes medication levels that kept rising to make other people more comfortable, and a research literature built almost entirely around people in crisis. She also describes what would make life better: a cultural shift that would see, in BPD, not a defective kind of person, but just a different kind of person.
Justin Garson: There’s this idea that people take psychiatric drugs to manage parts of themselves that are inherently distressing, like being depressed or anxious. But as you point out in your paper, people with BPD often take medications for the sake of others. You describe how other people want to “erase—literally—who we are for their own comfort.” Can you say more about this idea of taking drugs to erase one’s personality?
Shay Welch: It’s true that you have these categories of social anxiety, panic attacks, and chronic deep depression, and those can interfere with somebody’s ability to thrive. But then you have these “identity” disorders, like BPD and bipolar and schizophrenia, which make other people very uncomfortable. When it comes to bipolar, or BPD, or schizophrenia, the institutions or the medical field itself will try to medicate it completely out of them. And then you just completely eliminate the person. These people are like, “I’m not a person. I am so medicated, I don’t exist as an individual.”
So, we are constantly trying to back off the medication to hit a point where we’re still satisfying other people, but reclaiming more of our actual identity. But that’s when people say, “you’ve come off your meds too much, and now you’re not functioning well in society and you need to go back on your meds.” And then people like us are like, what do I do? I’m terribly unhappy, but it’s me versus all of them. That causes many people to isolate themselves.
For example, a lot of bipolar people really love their mania. They accomplish so much, and their lives are so colorful, when they’re in the manic state. Then they have to go into the depression state. But sometimes they’ll tolerate the depression for the mania—especially if your manic state is longer than the depressive state. But other people don’t like that. For others, it’s too intense or erratic.
Garson: That makes sense. My dad was bipolar and he was on medication mainly because people didn’t like his manic episodes. In general, he didn’t like medication—he enjoyed having those emotional extremes.
But it seems to me—and this is something you get at in your paper—that for schizophrenia or bipolar disorder, there’s a sense that “we’re treating your symptoms,” like hallucinations or manic episodes. Whereas for BPD, the “problem,” as it were, is you. The message is that your very personality is at fault.
Welch: Right. What makes these “personality disorders” is that there’s a problem with your personality. I’ve often been told that I’m too boisterous for other people. Even when I medicate, I project my voice. I’m very straightforward and very blunt, but I’m always enthusiastic, like, let’s go. I’m driven. Before I was medicated, people didn’t like that.
And it’s true that when you’re not medicated for borderline, you do have these spillovers. I spent my whole life having random episodes where my affective regulation—the top just blows off. When you go off that big, you don’t come back without a whole lot of negative consequences and personal damage, and maybe damage to other people.
So, I’ve spent a lot of time trying to find the least amount of medication that would make me interact with other people to their satisfaction. And I thought I had succeeded, and I had found the right level of medication that made other people happy—but it turned out that wasn’t enough. I finally medicated to a degree that I lost interest in everything. I’ve lost 80% of who I was.
Garson: If it’s not too personal, what would be an example of going over the edge?
Welch: I would get super amped up, and I’m like, it’s time for an adventure. I would go out into the world and approach strangers and be like, “Let’s have an adventure.” And it would just roll. I could grab people and snowball it and make it bigger and bigger. As with all snowballs, eventually it hits something and bursts, and I’m left with the fallout.
One of the things I mention in the paper is that everybody loves the ride. Everybody wants to jump on that train, especially because 80% of the time it doesn’t hit that point where it goes crazy. People are like, “This is fun. This is exciting. I want to live vicariously through you.” And then if they happen to be with me when I went over the edge, all of a sudden they’re like, “You’re a terrible person,” or “You’re irresponsible.” And I’m like, you’re the one who wanted to play this game. You’re the one who enjoys this part of me when it doesn’t go over your limit.
I’ve had a lot of people purposely come into my life and then purposefully leave my life, which is sort of why I stick to myself for the most part.
Garson: When it comes to BPD, what would a more ideal society look like? I know that for my dad’s bipolar, a more ideal society would be one in which people are more tolerant and accepting of differences. How would you prefer people interacting with you?
Welch: There are people who are very tolerant toward BPD people. I know that people get really concerned about dangerous things. For example, people are concerned about suicide. But my suspicion is that a lot of the suicides and self-harming behaviors are responses to other people. Maybe a better world would be where people don’t look at people like me and think that we’re bad people, but that we’re just a kind of person. So, I’d like to see more of a recognition that this kind of person is this kind of way.
For example, there are autistic people who are very blunt and straightforward; they don’t chitchat. I’m that way. And that makes a lot of people uncomfortable. With autism, you usually have to have a highly recognizable form of autism before people say, “OK, we need to let this person be that way because of their autism.” I would happily wear a little tag. If I walked around with BPD, and I was acting my sort of way, people would say, “Yes, that all translates well, I understand this person.” And people try to adjust to each other. When people police me, it makes me much more resistant to interacting with them in the way they want to.
Garson: If you lived in a world where people were more tolerant of your personality, do you think you would have any reason to continue taking medication?
Welch: I think it was a good thing for me to take some medication. I started after something had gone very wrong in a social situation, during a time when I was going through something in my personal life. Somebody said something very, very specific to me, and I was like, people don’t want me here. That was when I attempted suicide.
Then I got my little medication—75 milligrams—and I was like, this is good. It got rid of 70% of the snowball. But it just wasn’t enough for other people, and I had to keep going until I got to 300. And then I just completely lost interest in everything.
My nickname used to be Super Shay. It was on my car, on my work name tags. I killed off Super Shay when I was 36, 37, when the suicide attempts happened. And now if I just have to knock off Shay to make sure that I don’t end up homeless or something of the sort, have at it. If I just have to chill and coast for a while, fine. I was getting tired anyways.
Garson: As you mentioned, one of the most concerning things about BPD is suicide. Estimates (here and here) hold that between 5% to 10% of people diagnosed with BPD die by suicide, and up to 70% make suicide attempts. To what extent are suicide and suicide attempts responses to other people not being able to accept their personalities? Do you think that rate would drop if people were more accommodating and accepting?
Welch: I can’t speak for the history of people with BPD, but I can say that for every single person in my life that I know who has BPD, suicide attempts are 100% a result of other people’s reactions to them. And I’ve never read a single thing in the academic literature that says this—that BPD people act out this way or have these responses or engage in self harm or suicidal behavior because of the way they are treated, either by other people with whom they’re in relationships, or by the medical institution itself. That is one of the reasons I’ve been writing about it.
The research is done on a very small sample of people. Say somebody is a really successful scholar in psychiatry. The only people they’re really writing about are the people in their practice. Let’s be generous and say 100 people—100 people who are in crisis—and then they make a standard canon of research about what BPD is.
My psychiatrist, who I adore, recognizes that my testimony is completely reliable. She lets me make all of my medication decisions. No other therapist or psychiatrist has ever interacted with me in that way. I can message her and say, “I really almost committed suicide, and I think we need to talk about a new medication,” and she’ll call me on the phone at 8 o’clock at night and say, “So what happened?” She never thinks that she needs to call the police on me, because she knows I’m responsible enough to tell her. And she’s like, “This is 100% not your fault.”
Garson: As a society, we seem willing to talk about BPD in ways that we would never talk about any other mental disorder, or any other marginalized group. People with BPD are described as manipulative, attention-seeking, calculating. Why do you think that is?
Welch: I think it’s because sometimes we can engage in really degrading behavior. We’re the ones who can really go off the deep end and violate a lot of social and ethical norms. But when people think that we’re manipulative, that’s just crazy. People navigate each other. Normal people do that in relationships.
I have been a go-to person to run things because of my disposition. I make things happen. People can rely on me. Those are all aspects of my BPD. But nobody wants to give me credit for those things. They just want to see my marginal spin-out behavior and say, “We don’t want that.”
People with BPD do need that assurance of safety, that assurance of acceptance. I’ve run things at FEAST [the Association for Feminist Ethics and Social Theory] for years, and never have I had a spin-out there. Never. Because I’m with people who I know genuinely love me. Maybe it’s a big ask, to need people to be with you in a loving way in a professional environment. But that’s the way I stay grounded. What would the world look like? It would be somebody who knows me really well just sticking with me and saying, “I’ve got your back. You’re with me. It’s safe.”













Surely there can be no such thing as a ‘person with BPD’? Of all the spurious labels invented by psychiatry, this is the least credible – in fact both DSM and ICD considered dropping it altogether. Isn’t that the best – indeed the only sensible- way forward?
Report comment
In my view – and this is what I’ve argued for a long time regarding ADHD, depression, and other problems – the answer isn’t always to get rid of the labels, but to take them outside of the pathology framework.
Report comment
completely vehemently disagree as one harmed, one who reads and looks around
like keeping slavery but enslaving all peoples
like supporting the Catholic Church but making women deacons
like voting out the Republicans but not impeaching Trump
I think I could push myself to go on
like returning to the medicalizing, the pathologizing, of sexuality but saying were are all sick to have any kind of sex
like saying Psychiatry should never make a statement condemning and apologizing for Walter Freeman and lobotomy, because at least he tried
like saying Psychiatry should never make a statement about so called Christian counselling because Psychiatry is after all a business
Report comment
But, Justin, if “depression” is no longer caused by a “depressive disorder” then it is, of course, merely caused by depression: Our feelings of hopelessness are caused by a lack of hope, for whatever reason/s, and not by some supposed illness of mind or of “personalty,” by some depressive illness/disorder, by some congenital or acquired neurotransmitter deficiency or by a mysterious endogenous actual lack of some re-uptake inhibitor, so that the very label dissolves, has no meaning.
And, If “ADHD” is no longer a disorder, then the reason a heterosexual teenaged boy cannot, will not or does not muster the same levels of attentiveness for math problems in a classroom as he might for a female stripper is because of a lack of curiosity and/or patience and/or motivation and/or an overdose of boredom and not because of some “neurodevelopmental disorder,” or some amphetamine deficiency or methylphenidate defiency or xanthine deficiency, after all, is it?
So that label is shredded too, is it not?
(Mind you, in my own defence, one cannot altogether rule out a lifelong FDS’s (fetal decaffeination syndrome’s) having given rise to my my moths of prenatal and decades of postpartum clinical depression, coupled with an acute ADHD and FPD (Flibbertigibbet Personality Disorder) resulting from Mom’s promptly going clean off her coffee each time she became pregnant, can one?)
I find Minute 22:58-24:16 of this
https://youtu.be/qINdA6E14Sk?is=iE5oB20pbzYSWq_Q
particularly enlightening, even given that it is conjecture
In the good old days, hundreds of millennia ago, when not fulfilling our assigned roles in a tribe or clan might have meant expulsion and death, we may have developed fight-and-flight fearful reflexes – emotions – which served our physical survival…as well as labels to remind us of our (essential?) assigned roles in those primitive early societies.
Being so very much smarter rather than us, rather than, as (Judaeo-Sauline) Science and Neuroscience would have us believe, so very much stupider than us, through the persistence of both such tendencies, Nature may have equipped us with the wherewithal and the drive to now consciously evolve past such instincts…and past all labels?
By turning up our existential discomfort, Nature may be nudging us to higher levels of consciousness as we painfully learn that “medicating” – drugging, poisoning – ourselves to lower levels is not the way to go?
Wishing you comfort and joy and the peace that passes all understanding,
Tom.
Report comment
Since psychiatry’s pseudo-scientific stigmatizing DSM labels such as “schizoaffective disorder,” BPD, ADHD, and numerous other purely speculative categories of mental illness have already acquired such a negative connotation among the general public (misled in large part by deceptive advertising), I don’t see how they can really be “de-pathologized.” The interest of the APA guild and its compliant enablers in academia, the media, and the pharmaceutical industry in maintaining this profitable deception would be hard to overcome.
Emotional distress shouldn’t and needn’t be reduced to facile categories fraught with negative associations.
Report comment
I would consider autism. Over the last 20 years, it’s been shifted from the pathology paradigm to the neurodiversity paradigm. People can, of course, debate whether it’s helpful that the category has expanded to include so many. But to me, that serves as a kind of proof of concept that we could do the same with BPD (Incidentally, I do believe we are doing this with ADHD as well.)
Report comment
Justin, I’m not sure whether the so-called autism spectrum has actually shifted from a pathology paradigm to a less stigmatizing neurodiversity category. The label of autism often continues to evoke negative images of a socially inept, emotionally crippled loner tormented by obsessive thoughts and driven by compulsive behaviors.
It might be best to drop this traditionally pejorative label altogether, along with other dubious ones such as ADHD and BPD, all of which were voted into existence by DSM panels without rigorous, verifiable testing and experimentation.
Report comment
Dear Justin,
How could a fictional disorder with no biological basis be removed from a pathological framework if it has no underlying pathology? It would be the equivalent of relocating nothing to nowhere.
Are you aware that, apart from identical twins, everyone is neurodivergent (Gøtzsche, 2026), and that placing ‘BPD’ in this category would serve no purpose other than to continue the oppression to which people misdiagnosed with this fictional disorder (predominantly women who have been sexually violated) are already subjected?
Kind regards,
Cat
Report comment
Cat, your logic is irrefutable!
Indeed, how can a state of mind that didn’t arise from a demonstrable (not hypothetical) organic pathology be diagnosed and treated as a real disorder in the first place?
That’s a prime example of the self-serving deception that psychiatry engages in to justify its status as a legitimate science or branch of medicine.
Report comment
Very well said Cat, and factually grounded to boot! The thrust here is a better clinical fiction begetting a more attractive social narrative engendering an expanding buy-in from the public-and their wallets, be it pills or bobblehead therapist…
Report comment
I don’t think you can neatly separate pathologisation from any medical framing of human behaviour, its inherent. The words medicalise and pathologise are practically synonymous.
I think “pathologisation” means much more than simply “negative” attitudes or stigma. Harmful pathologisation can mean *falsely* identifying something as a medical disease/illness/disorder/pathology. It is harmful because it is a *misidentification*. For example, when someone is angry at our behaviour, and we tell them they are just angry because of their “hormones” – we are pathologising their justified anger by making it look like a medical condition – we are deliberately decontextualising it.
When we say that anger is caused by a “disordered personality” we are doing the same thing – decontextualising their behaviour from the situation and obscuring its reasons. This is why it’s so infuriating when it is done to us, because pathologisation is the mechanism which justifies dismissing, invalidating and distancing ourselves from another’s feelings.
Pathologising human behaviour not only decontextualises it – it frames it as outside of our control. This might appear to free us from blame or stigma, but it does so by denying our agency. Once our perceived agency has been explained away by a medical pathology – that exposes us to other much more harmful effects of unjustified pathologisation and medicalisation. That pathology is easily used to frame us as lacking capacity and control – in order to justify the removal of our rights – by those who claim the authority to name that pathology through (unproven) medical constructs like “diagnoses.”
This effect of pathologisation tends to be concealed by those promoting the idea of diagnoses as identities, and of pathologisation as simply negative attitudes we can just change. They rely on exactly the same medicalised narrative to build an identity, which is used to justify the removal of human rights and forced treatment. It’s untenable as an ideology of supposed “liberation.”
Report comment
I believe you’ve hit on an important point, Freya. But I’d say that decontextualization precedes pathologizing, and does because it is the (systemic) ground that engenders pathologizing. On this point I would reference several passages from Lynne Layton’s excellent book “Toward A Social Psychoanalysis”, where Layton quotes several great thinkers who say-I paraphrase- that the professionalized establishment exercise and maintain power by dehistoricizing and universalizing individuals in society, to reflect PMC interest and maintain and increase their power. My larger point here is that the mental health professions have been educated and credentialed to reproduce this effect throughout society like every other institutional profession, and therefor are largely unable to recognize the pathologies they carry and therefor can inflict. IMO, this is what makes psychiatric diagnoses so pernicious: its a compelling if not convincing (faux) story, but the story it systematically conceals and ‘suppresses’, is very often the most substantively reparative story for the diagnosed person, but ‘also’ everyone in the diagnosed persons orbit.
Report comment
Thanks Kevin, that’s a really great comment! As you say, decontextualising is the action and the more salient point of pathologisation. I really appreciate your clarification, and the wider connections you’ve made here. I’ve been confused lately, by what could definitely be called a PMC interest in the psychiatric “debate”, which seems to reproduce and rely on exactly the same universalising and dehistoricised narratives.
I will check out the author!
Report comment
I’d like to add another distinction surrounding psychiatric diagnoses, apart from mental health clinicians dehistoricizing peoples lived experiences and thereby “reify- universalizing them through the lens of psychiatric diagnoses, and that distinction is “ideology”. Historically the state and religion have been the primary ways to organize, control (by force or consent) manipulate. But in today’s digital age and neoliberal fundamentalism, ideology has become a most useful/necessary tool of social and political control. I mention this because, when you break down psychiatry at its historical, scientific, epistemological, and theoretical ground, its primarily a praxis of ideology, which compliments and closes the loop of political and social control. But I don’t blame psychiatry for the mess professionalized mental health now finds itself, I blame the psych-disciplines and the professionals and organizations that willingly and shameless were content to be psychiatry’s handmaidens…Sorry if I sound pedantic and all! But I’ve become so disgusted and disillusioned with the entire PMC, that I no longer give a rats ass how bad I sound in expressing myself with this fact.
Report comment
You don’t sound pedantic at all Kevin! But I may be equally pedantic and 😀
I agree that psychiatry is 100% ideological. And I agree the entire psy-industry is constructed around this confabulation of “mental health”. I would add, now, a growing class of “symbolic capitalists” generating circular debates, which equally depend on the perpetuation of the concept, and of the whole industry. (Excluding organisations like MIA and a few others, of course! All those who continue to critically centre the material harm being done!)
So I feel your disgust!
I guess psychiatry is the main head of the Hydra in my view, because it has the material power to enforce that ideology, and uses it to intervene on, and harm, real bodies.
Being essentially ideological makes psychiatry more powerful. Because it is, at its centre, epistemically (and morally) vacuous – it can simply adjust the story to suit the times and deflect any criticism – cut off one head, and it grows another.
Report comment
Thank you so much for your work!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
https://www.bps.org.uk/member-networks/division-clinical-psychology/power-threat-meaning-framework
Report comment
I completely agree – we don’t need labels to understand people – they actually shut down understanding.
The problem of making any diagnosis into an identity for me is that it restricts diverse experiences into very narrow channels of meaning. A meaning that is imposed by an institution which has very different motivations (“treatment”, control, management) to the motivations of the individual (understanding, belonging, care).
I also question what the BPD diagnosis contributes to understanding behaviour – which is not better and less stigmatised explanations understandings of post-traumatic reactions?
We can rehabilitate diagnoses one by one – but only by making them more “acceptable” – less like what they actually are – painful, messy, confusing and outside many people’s idea of what humans are suppose to be – rational, transparent, orderly. Some experiences are not pretty, or easy to understand, or perfectly transparent to ourselves or others. But they are much more understandable when viewed in context, as meaningful reactions, than as fixed and unchangeable personalities.
I don’t believe making diagnoses into “types” increases our tolerance of difference – it actually narrows it by reducing diversity to impoverished stereotypes of behaviour which were never designed to understand human difference but to contain it. Classing people into “types” is the same logic underlying eugenics – it’s something I think we should resist.
Report comment
I know Mad allows a variety of voices, an openness I both applaud, and dislike. Because of articles like this one. Same problem with my old writers group of mad divergent female writers. Some are educated regarding the nonsense of labels; some still use them. Chaos.
I am wondering why the heck this well educated woman accepts the 100% objectionable (on so many levels) label at all!?! Why? It’s not scientific and it oozes in so much objectionable historical facts, including colonial history of which slavery is a part, and it keeps alive societal witch hunts for women, as the subject seems to understand to some degree.
But peace to you, human. Thanks author. Will check out your new book. Thanks Mad.
Me? WTeff? Oh boy. Justice will be impossible. Oakland Community College sexist gaslight bogus mental health care witchhunt. Not news.
WAIT!!! What? From the publisher’s webpage about the author’s work: “Using first-hand research and interviews, THE MADNESS PILL is at once a raucous history and insightful portrait of a remarkable scientist who turned psychiatry into a respected science by transforming how mental illness is treated.”
respected science?
WHAT???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? I keep a list of books I recommend and one for those I don’t recommend (after reading them).
Report comment
My response to you is the same as my response to Lucy‘s above: in general I *don’t* think we should get rid of labels like BPD, ADHD, depression. We should rather remove them from the pathologizing framework that can only see defects or dysfunctions.
Also, you might be surprised to know that authors generally have no control over the way the publisher wishes to promote their book – even including the title, the subtitle, and the back cover blurbs.
Report comment
likes saying mansplaining is okay because . . . . .
like saying no to any disorders regarding racism, sexism, classism, because . . .
oh well
smile
https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/thelma-louise-and-women-in-hollywood/?srsltid=AYCX9vIo2XF0liXhCQvhZ6xKL1BjoVvFN27jdQVdVyJsd8dpKKFrpEBW
thanks!
(I’ve learned, so some books I think I may not like go to the end of the line!)
smile!
peace!
Report comment
If public/political forms of oppression were the only reason for mental disorders (and certainly they can contribute mightily), there wouldn’t be anyone who was white, male, able-bodied, heterosexual and middle-class who had one.
Report comment
I can’t agree. Most white male able bodied etc people experience oppression in various form. All of them have families, the vast majority have to attend school at large bureaucratic institutions, most have to work for oppressive corporate entities whose job is to exploit them economically. The idea that people who suffer less from oppressive conditions therefore don’t experience oppression is an important myth to overcome.
Report comment
Dear Oliver,
The ‘only reason for mental disorders’ is that the American Psychiatric Association and a committee of fools, the majority of whose members receive financial incentives from Big Pharma, invented them. They are then adopted worldwide by ignorant clowns to discredit, drug and detain individuals who are deemed lebensunwertes Leben (life unworthy of life) — this includes ‘white, male, able-bodied, heterosexual and middle-class’ individuals. It is nothing more than necropolitics, and eugenics without the gas chambers: Diet Aktion T4.
Kind regards,
Cat
Report comment
Cat,
I only wish that more were ignorant clowns. Unfortunately, way too many are corrupt scumbags who know only too well exactly what they are doing.
Report comment
Hi Gina Fournier,
While I agree with a lot of what you’re saying, could you explain this sentence please: “It’s not scientific and it oozes in so much objectionable historical facts, including colonial history of which slavery is a part” ?
I think I understand in which way the psychiatric narrative can reinforce patriarchy especially regarding the BPD, but I’m not sure what you meant on how it includes colonial history.
On another note, even though I agree that psychiatry is not scientific, I’m not sure we should entirely use this argument in our critic of psychiatry. Science should not become a new religion in my opinion.
Not everything that isn’t proved scientifially is shallow or bad. I think we should even be more open to animistic ways of relating to the world, not because it’s trendy or new age, but because it’s part of who we are. That doesn’t mean we have to forget science, on the contrary, it is necessary, but it’s not the whole picture.
We are not just rational beings.
Report comment
Vera, I agree that science ought not to become an incontrovertible doctrine (“scientism). However, psychiatry does claim to be, and seeks acceptance as, a full-fledged branch of medicine, whose diagnoses and treatments must be based on rigorous verifiable methods. Were the hundreds of putative disorders enumerated in the DSM discovered through extensive testing and experimentation, or merely hypothesized into (and sometimes out of) existence by majority vote?
Report comment
I wonder if either philosopher, Justin or Shay, might care to offer us a or their definition of “personality,” please – and perhaps also what they make of Jung’s “personas,” too, please, and/or even of Eckhart Tolle’s “subpersonalities?”
Once we know what a “personality” is, if anyone does, or what they mean by the term, then perhaps we can know what a nondisordered one might be, in their view, and/or how to recognize it (perhaps as that only one among us who actually got off on the right planet, for instance?)?
Very best wishes.
Tom.
“The meaning of life is to help others find meaning.”
“‘PersonALity disorder?!’ Ya can’t have ‘a personALity disorder!’ Your personality? – that’s, like, who you ARE! That’s, like, THEEEEE Rudest Thing, Ever!” – Elizabeth, then 16, passionately, but without covering my face in spittle, or convincing me that it is, like, who you are…
Report comment
Peter Breggin called this Spellbinding. It’s another qualification for abolishing psychiatry.
Report comment
Chris, I understand and share your antimus toward psychiatry, but from a purely logical point of view it can’t be abolished by a judicial fiat or executive decree.
This faux profession is based on half-truths and myths, which can’t be formally abolished; the best way to counter its fallacies is by disproving them with more convincing arguments and solid evidence.
That’s precisely how the concept of the body’s four humors, eugenics, phrenology, and Lombroso’s physiognomy-based criminology and theory of degeneration fell out of favor into the dustbin of history, together with other discredited pseudo-sciences.
Report comment
Not everyone loves mania in others, “living vicariously” through them, thank you very much.
Some people, like the spouses of people in the throes of mania, find it terrifying. They may also resent their other half leaping out into life and snowballing around while they are left to take care of the kids, the house, the finances… They may wonder whether they are actually enabling the manic spouse to continue their seesawing behavior, as they always pick up the pieces afterward.
It’s very self-centered, perhaps selfish, for anyone who admits they are manic to just expect everyone around them to accommodate their quirks. We all have quirks, secret desires, emotional sensitivities – most of us subdue them when necessary in order to avoid hurting others. I don’t think we should condone behavior that does hurt others just because someone has a diagnosis, or because someone has a quirk that they call “just being me.”
I am also not saying that people should medicate themselves in order to avoid hurting others. But if they are unable to find a better way then perhaps they should consider it as a last resort?
Report comment
Go to the sourse of the problem, not unscientific psychiatry or the drugs that do harm.
https://cepuk.org/
Report comment
I personally found this article extremely discouraging and depressing. I’ve worked with lots of people over time who got this label, and it seems to me that the core issues In most cases involved abuse/neglect at a young age, where the victim receives the essential message, “YOU are wrong to be who you are; your needs are irritating or inconvenient; and that you need to truncate or eliminate important parts of yourself in order to survive. Yet the message from the system via this author is that who YOU are has to be drugged away for the convenience of others who find you annoying!
The saddest part for me is that the author seems to accept this framing and believe that a 70% elimination of their identity is acceptable or even optimum. I’m sorry, but being forced to delete who we are is the problem, not the solution!
When I have been of most help to such individuals (who BTW I generally enjoy and who for the most part seem to find me very helpful!) is when I could create a safe space where they felt able to let down their guard and do “inappropriate” things, and to be met with humor, warmth and good boundaries. Instead, we put them into a system where they learn that their abusive parents were correct: THEY are the problem and need to learn to expect less and ask less of caretakers who actually don’t even like them very much.
Report comment
Why Mad in America continues to publish such absolute drivel is beyond comprehension. Not only does this article promote hypothetical disorders funded by Big Pharma, but it also actively harms the uneducated, violated, and/or oppressed by feeding them falsehoods. These authors, along with MIA, have an ethical responsibility not to deceive the public with their deluded and foolish concepts. Absolute bullshit. Zero stars.
Report comment
I hear your pain, Cat. I understand the openness, but not the chaos. It just confuses more people and it hurts more the people already hurt.
Report comment
Dear Gina,
To which particular chaos are you referring? Is it Professor Chaos? Which people are confused, and which hurt people have been hurt further as a direct result of my insignificant opinion? Perhaps, given your previous ‘chaotic’ statement, ‘I have been brain raped on order by me by my rapist Jesus, Catholic effing Jesus’, it is I who am confused and hurt.
Kind regards,
Cat
Report comment
Cat, man, woman, child (the chaos of not using real names), you read me wrong and are projecting, please fake white colonial christian god the effer delusional Jesus my metaphoric rapist at Trinity Health Livonia (suicide swatting by EEOC documented abusive employer, police manhandling from sexist pig Caucasian men, non evaluation by Dr. Andrew Muzychka) stop please. too much, too long, must still speak! oakland community college sexist gaslight bogus mental health care wtichhunt since 2013. I was not thinking of your posts or what you posted, Cat, with the word “chaos,” which I had already used in this thread (posts show out of order). I was trying to say I agree about wondering why MAD published this piece at all. Psychiatry got you a little tender too? When people who know the labels are crap mix with people who don’t know or refuse to accept that the labels are crap, chaos ensues. Be hurt when someone effs one directly, I suggest. Feel pain when a crap article like this one appears in MIA, and one know things will never improve in one’s life time, I suggest. Peace.
Report comment
man, woman, child (the chaos of not using real names), don’t read me wrong and project. please fake white colonial christian god the effer delusional Jesus my metaphoric rapist at Trinity Health Livonia (suicide swatting by EEOC documented abusive employer, police manhandling from sexist pig Caucasian men, non evaluation by Dr. Andrew Muzychka). too much, too long, must still speak! oakland community college sexist gaslight bogus mental health care wtichhunt since 2013. I was not thinking of your posts or what you posted, with the word “chaos,” which I had already used in this thread (posts show out of order). I was trying to say I agree about wondering why MAD published this piece at all. Psychiatry got others a little tender too? When people who know the labels are crap mix with people who don’t know or refuse to accept that the labels are crap, chaos ensues. Be hurt when someone effs one directly, I suggest. Feel pain when a crap article like this one appears in MIA, and one know things will never improve in one’s life time, I suggest. Peace.
Report comment
Is not the definition of terms at the core or philosophy, the “alpha and omega of logic,” as Will Durant is reported to have pointed out?
I would once more ask Justin and Shay, please, to at least attempt to define what they understand/mean by “a personality” and then by “a personality disorder,” or else to (preferably goodhumoredly, even joyfully) admit that they cannot.
I believe that “tv personalities” exist and that we may all, at different times, have exbibited or manifested or modeled or portrayed various different “personas” in the Jungian sense, acting our our perceived roles as we thought expected/required of us.
I cannot imagine what a tv personality disorder or a persona disorder could possibly be, and, failing to understand what a “personality,” much less what a “borderline personality” could possibly be, I am at a complete loss to imagine what any “personality disorder,” much less a “borderline personality disorder” might consist of.
As for “ADHD,” so with every other supposed mental disorder, personality disorder, syndrome/spectrum/continuum: There being no agreed point or line demarcating differentiation/distinction/division between what is “normal” and not among clinicians, psychologists, psychiatrists, sociologists, philosophers, social media users or members of society, once again, there is no definition of terms, but, it may be argued, no want of fools arguing with fools about foolishness.
My opinion is that every human being is always doing their very best, and that we can and will all always do better – that we are at least infinitely pluperfect works-in-progress, and each perfectly normal for us.
Actual, demonstrable diseases and disorders affecting the brain and neuroendocrine system etc. are another matter, of course, actually being material.
Comfort and JOY!
Tom.
Report comment
Read the latest article on the non disorder for the connection to colonialism; psychiatry has served as mental invasion forever no science just power plays.
Power play right back! My day dream! I wish all who hurt me with their ahhfucking nonsense including crap journalism (many examples including NYT) about psychiatry could be brain raped like I have been brain raped on order by me by my rapist Jesus, Catholic effing Jesus, of all the miscreants. Metaphor for Dr. Andrew Muzychka. Trinity Health Livonia. No evaluation by Dr Andrew Muzychka. Human trafficked. Oakland Community College sexist gaslight bogus mental health care witchhunt.
“If public/political forms of oppression were the only reason for mental disorders (and certainly they can contribute mightily), there wouldn’t be anyone who was white, male, able-bodied, heterosexual and middle-class who had one.”
Misogynist pigism is blind.
Psychiatry is such a fraud, so we have no figures for diagnoses. Apart from Ben Affleck and Kanye West and other idiot media people, most/more pernicious labels are probably applied to women.
Wake up.
I had a night dream. Joan of arc time. Gather fire wood and matches!
Online I am hacked and harassed every mothereff of shit Jesus day since 2013. This discussion is effing crap. Psychiatry is killing me.
Report comment
Steve, you don’t REALLY let foolishness fool you – discourage or depress you, do you?
And you don’t REALLY believe there are scumbags and those who are not, do you?
Are there two kinds of people in our worlds or are there not?
Looking into the Abyss, for Bliss,
Tom.
Report comment
There are two kinds of people in this world:
Those who divide the people of the world into two groups.
And those who don’t.
Report comment
And all we need is to grasp just that, thank you, Steve!
End of “sin,” of “mental disorders,” of psycho pharmacology, and of MIA!
Much love.
Tom.
Report comment
crap and trolled! no surprise!
Report comment
me? crap? i am impressed.
Report comment
It only gets worse!
I have been deemed effing nutz by psychiatry. You decide. There is no such thing as the DSM. Why in the world are you feeding the sexist racist colonial beast of psychiatry your flesh? Of course ignorance spreads and hurts others too. Ask for a reading list if you want. Declassroommed community college English teacher slowly being raped brain life dead by retaliatory criminal unprosecuted psychiatry since 2013. Oakland Community College sexist gaslight bogus mental health care witchhunt
The mirror speaks angrily. Why in the world do you feel entitled to both my personal lived experience and my experience and my work with BPD non profits. Mind your business and don’t be a parasite.
My thoughts to myself or maybe someone acting up to a ridiculous label: Because one put oneselves out there, here in MIA, as an academic, the kind of worker generally supposedly interested in discourse and evidence. Because I care that some people are dragging the societal conversation down and probably hurting themselves and others with tragically bad information.
Of course a real academic would NEVER say this, so you know I’m making it up!
You sound a bit hysterical.
If any academic accused me of being “hysterical” for maybe being the first to tell a a person that BPD does not exist, I would think, Great! This is exactly what the beast of psychiatry does! Exactly! My point!
If this conversation were to happen, I would definitely respond How ridiculous. I will contact your administrators and put this in the thread. Are you saying your education was that poor? Are you saying an education at U of USA is that poor? Whoa! Way out of line. And so misinformed about psychiatry! Still, best wishes! And have great day! (What an academic colleague said as he threw me under the bus.)
There is no hope, but that’s not news. Those of us effed by psychiatry like the last word. Maybe I am convinced! Maybe there is BPD after all, Jesus! Maybe some poor broads (a phrase my father would say) beaten by the still effing colonial male power eff, are so wacky because of it, they would say something like this using their professional account.
Apparently, my reaction feels extremely disproportionate to my original uninvited harassment. Strange and mysterious, indeed.
Dr. of What?
Associate Professor of What?
Any Can Teach Here College
Faculty and Advisory Board Member, Center For Mind, Brain, and Culture at some other campus spreading misinformation USA
Research Associate, African Centre of Epistemology and Philosophy of Science
University of Spreads More Misinformation Globally
If actually one called another hysterical for being accurate, one of them will be reporting to the other one’s supervisors. You betcha! In a much kinder rebuke with links to the Power Threat Meaning Framework and The Council for Evidenced-Based Psychiatry.
So many students, people, Americans are suffering misinformation. Peace!
Report comment
It only gets worse!
I have been deemed effing nutz by psychiatry. All are free to decide and punch back. There is no such thing as the DSM. Why in the world would anyone feed the sexist racist colonial beast of psychiatry one’s flesh? Of course ignorance spreads and hurts others too. Ask for a reading list. Declassroommed community college English teacher slowly being raped brain life dead by retaliatory criminal unprosecuted psychiatry since 2013. Oakland Community College sexist gaslight bogus mental health care witchhunt
The mirror speaks angrily. Why in the world does anyone feel entitled to both a person’s lived experience and a person’s experience and a person’s work with BPD non profits. Mind one’s own business and don’t anyone be a parasite.
My thoughts to myself or maybe someone acting up to a ridiculous label. Because one put one’s self out there, here in MIA, as an academic, the kind of worker generally supposedly interested in discourse and evidence. Because some care that some people are dragging the societal conversation down and probably hurting themselves and others with tragically bad information.
Of course a real academic would NEVER say this, so you know I’m making it up!
Someone sounds a bit hysterical.
If any academic accused another of being “hysterical” for maybe being the first to tell a person that BPD does not exist, Gina would think, Great! This is exactly what the beast of psychiatry does! Exactly! My point!
If this conversation were to happen, Gina would definitely respond How ridiculous. She did contact your administrators and try to put this comment in this thread. Was one’s education that poor? Is an education at U of USA that poor? Whoa! Way out of line. And so misinformed about psychiatry! There is no hope if the academics spread misinformation. Still, best wishes! And have great day! (What an academic colleague said in writing as he threw Gina under the bus.)
There is no hope, but that’s not news. People effed by psychiatry like the last word. Maybe Gina is convinced! Maybe there is BPD after all, Jesus! Maybe some poor broads (a phrase one’s father would say) beaten by the still effing colonial male power eff, are so wacky because of it, they would say something like this using their professional account.
Apparently, this reaction feels extremely disproportionate to the original uninvited harassment. Strange and mysterious, indeed.
Dr. of What?
Associate Professor of What?
Any Can Teach Here College
Faculty and Advisory Board Member, Center For Mind, Brain, and Culture at some other campus spreading misinformation USA
Research Associate, African Centre of Epistemology and Philosophy of Science
University of Spreads More Misinformation Globally
If actually one called another hysterical for being accurate, the other has already reported to her supervisors. You betcha! In a much kinder rebuke with links to the Power Threat Meaning Framework and The Council for Evidenced-Based Psychiatry.
So many students, people, Americans are suffering misinformation. Peace!
Report comment
“But I don’t blame psychiatry for the mess professionalized mental health now finds itself, I blame the psych-disciplines and the professionals and organizations that willingly and shameless were content to be psychiatry’s handmaidens…Sorry if I sound pedantic and all! But I’ve become so disgusted and disillusioned with the entire PMC, that I no longer give a rats ass how bad I sound in expressing myself with this fact.”
Pedantic, the first part, with a weak conclusion, please allow. (How would it sound in lay language?)
Of course blame the source, psychiatry! That’s like saying ban slavery but keep the racism, sexism and classism, and no prosecution or accountability for the slave masters!!!!
I liked the talk about religion and ideology however (before the quote, the pedantic part). In simple terms, my simple terms, people grab onto a few beliefs and hold them, tightly, no ongoing or extra reading needed, otherwise their running for their lives most of the day and night.
I also like holding the Nazi guards at St. Mary Merciless Trinity Health Livonia Michigan completely legally accountable for human trafficking me. The statute is still good in the mitten state, a real sewer of corruption, under Republicans and Dems. Psychiatry and religion together make it way too easy for my society to run over me. And it will never be okay.
Report comment
“I guess psychiatry is the main head of the Hydra in my view.”
Hello? Smile!
Academic ish dry talk with no research and few dynamic detailed examples like lively magazine writing in The Atlantic and The New Yorker, for example. Hydra metaphor is fine but elite ish, no? Style. So what. Whatever. Personal preference.
But yes of course the source is the heart of the problem. And a quote pretty much from Gloria Steinem’s memoir about life on the road. One lesson from the road. The people who experience something are the experts, not the experts!
Meanwhile. Ah delusional Jesus was the harassment of me thick today. But holding my own here helps. Thanks, Mad.
Report comment
PHYSICAL PAIN. HOW LONG CAN YOU ENDURE IT. Go on. 0 for for me, now argue for psychiatry. It gets very very complex for you/. when the definition of pain is obscured, it means i can rip you to threads.
Report comment